• About us
  • Buy Adspace
  • Contact
  • Hide Ads for Premium Members
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
ONLINE NEWS NIGERIA
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • International
    Sule Lamido, N45 BILLION DEBT, MKO Abiola, DoublE cheating, Nigeria, military junta

    N45 BILLION DEBT: MKO Abiola doubly cheated by Nigeria’s military junta

    Dr Sani Shinkafi, Zamfara State, State of emergency, PAPSD

    Calls for state of emergency in Zamfara misguided, unpatriotic — PAPSD

    Naira Marley, Coroner probe, of Mohbad’s wife, Mohbad

    Naira Marley calls for coroner probe of Mohbad’s wife, others

    Tulia Ackson, IPU president, Both sides, Action, Natasha Akpoti

    IPU president demands to hear from both sides before acting on Natasha’s matter

    Nigerian govt, 30% contract, Sokoto-Badagry, Highway project, David Umahi

    Nigerian govt approves 30% contract sum for Sokoto-Badagry highway project – Umahi

    Pope Francis, Hospital, Bronchitis, Health concerns

    Pope Francis admitted to hospital for bronchitis treatment amid ongoing health concerns

    Trending Tags

    • Trump Inauguration
    • United Stated
    • White House
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
  • Entertainment
    Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

    Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

    Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

    Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

    Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

    WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

    Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

    Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

    Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

    INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

    Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

    Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

    Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

    Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

    Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

    Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

    Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

    Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

    Trending Tags

    • Politics
      Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

      Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

      Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

      Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

      Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

      WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

      Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

      Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

      Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

      INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

      Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

      Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

      Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

      Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

      Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

      Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

      Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

      Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

      Trending Tags

      • International
        Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

        Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

        Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

        Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

        Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

        WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

        Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

        Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

        Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

        INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

        Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

        Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

        Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

        Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

        Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

        Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

        Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

        Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

        Trending Tags

        • Law
          Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

          Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

          Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

          Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

          Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

          WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

          Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

          Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

          Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

          INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

          Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

          Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

          Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

          Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

          Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

          Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

          Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

          Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

          Trending Tags

          • Security
            Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

            Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

            Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

            Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

            Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

            WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

            Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

            Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

            Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

            INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

            Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

            Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

            Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

            Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

            Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

            Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

            Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

            Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

            Trending Tags

            • Sports
              Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

              Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

              Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

              Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

              Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

              WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

              Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

              Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

              Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

              INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

              Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

              Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

              Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

              Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

              Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

              Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

              Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

              Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

              Trending Tags

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • All
                • International
                Sule Lamido, N45 BILLION DEBT, MKO Abiola, DoublE cheating, Nigeria, military junta

                N45 BILLION DEBT: MKO Abiola doubly cheated by Nigeria’s military junta

                Dr Sani Shinkafi, Zamfara State, State of emergency, PAPSD

                Calls for state of emergency in Zamfara misguided, unpatriotic — PAPSD

                Naira Marley, Coroner probe, of Mohbad’s wife, Mohbad

                Naira Marley calls for coroner probe of Mohbad’s wife, others

                Tulia Ackson, IPU president, Both sides, Action, Natasha Akpoti

                IPU president demands to hear from both sides before acting on Natasha’s matter

                Nigerian govt, 30% contract, Sokoto-Badagry, Highway project, David Umahi

                Nigerian govt approves 30% contract sum for Sokoto-Badagry highway project – Umahi

                Pope Francis, Hospital, Bronchitis, Health concerns

                Pope Francis admitted to hospital for bronchitis treatment amid ongoing health concerns

                Trending Tags

                • Trump Inauguration
                • United Stated
                • White House
                • Market Stories
                • Election Results
              • Entertainment
                Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

                Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

                Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

                Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

                Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

                WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

                Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

                Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

                Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

                INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

                Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

                Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

                Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

                Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

                Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

                Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

                Trending Tags

                • Politics
                  Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

                  Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

                  Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

                  Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

                  Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

                  WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

                  Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

                  Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

                  Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

                  INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

                  Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                  Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

                  Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                  Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

                  Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

                  Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

                  Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

                  Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

                  Trending Tags

                  • International
                    Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

                    Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

                    Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

                    Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

                    Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

                    WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

                    Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

                    Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

                    Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

                    INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

                    Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                    Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

                    Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                    Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

                    Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

                    Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

                    Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

                    Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

                    Trending Tags

                    • Law
                      Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

                      Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

                      Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

                      Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

                      Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

                      WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

                      Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

                      Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

                      Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

                      INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

                      Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                      Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

                      Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                      Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

                      Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

                      Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

                      Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

                      Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

                      Trending Tags

                      • Security
                        Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

                        Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

                        Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

                        Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

                        Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

                        WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

                        Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

                        Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

                        Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

                        INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

                        Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                        Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

                        Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                        Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

                        Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

                        Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

                        Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

                        Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

                        Trending Tags

                        • Sports
                          Deputy Sheriff, Gunfire, Florida State University

                          Deputy Sheriff’s son opens fire at Florida State University, two die, others injured

                          Pi Coin, Users, Withdrawal issues, Bitget, OKX, Cryptocurrency

                          Pi Coin users face withdrawal issues on Bitget, OKX

                          Mpox, Global emergency, Public health, WHO

                          WHO declares Mpox global public health emergency for second time in two years

                          Retirement, Euro 2024, Cristiano Ronaldo, Toni Kroos, Olivier Giroud, Luka Modric, Manuel Neuer, Kevin De Bruyne, Jan Vertonghen

                          Ronaldo, Kroos, Giroud, Modric, four other players who may retire after Euro 2024

                          Funke Egbemode, INTIMATE AFFAIRS, Unwise sacrifices

                          INTIMATE AFFAIRS: Unwise sacrifices, by Funke Egbemode

                          Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                          Nigeria Police claim arrest of kidnapper linked to Nabeeha’s death

                          Nigeria Police, Nabeeha, Kidnapper, Arrest

                          Police claims disruption of students’ abduction plans, arrest of suspects in Bwari kidnapping

                          Global food prices, Declined December 2023, FAO Report 

                          Global food prices declined December 2023 – Report 

                          Drambi Vandi, Bolanle Raheem Nigerian police officer, Death sentence, Shooting lawyer

                          Nigerian police officer sentenced to death for shooting lawyer dead

                          Trending Tags

                          No Result
                          View All Result
                          ONLINE NEWS NIGERIA
                          No Result
                          View All Result
                          Home Featured Opinon

                          admin by admin
                          March 21, 2022
                          in Opinon
                          0
                          Dr Musa Adamu Aliyu, Interrogating Power, INEC, Review, Return of Winner, Election, Returning Officer, Context of Constitution

                          Dr Musa Adamu Aliyu

                          0
                          SHARES
                          1
                          VIEWS
                          Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

                          Interrogating Power of INEC to Review Return of Winner of Election Made by its Returning Officer within the Context of Constitution (as amended) and Logic

                          By

                          Dr. Musa Adamu Aliyu,

                          Introduction

                          The recent decision of Honourable Justice E.N. Anyadike of the Federal High Court sitting in Umuahia in the case of Chief Nduka Edede v. Attorney-General of the Federation unreported Suit No. FHC/UM/CS/26/2022 is generating debates within the legal circle.

                          Section 65 (1) of the Electoral Act, 2022, has also raised a vital legal issue. The Section empowered the Independent Electoral Commission (INEC) to review the declaration and return made by its Returning Officer. The power may be exercised by the Commission on two grounds vis-à-vis where the declaration and return, was made contrary to law, or it was made by the Returning Officer under duress.

                          The provision gives the Commission, an executive body, seven (7) days within which to exercise the power which is judicial. This write-up seeks to criticize the provision and calling upon National Assembly to amend the provision or in the alternative, the Independent National Electoral Commission should be cautious in exercising the power.

                          Legality of Section 65 (1) of Electoral Act, 2022, within the Constitutional Framework

                          Governance in modern societies like ours is designed to safeguard abuse of power by any of the three arms of government. It is the responsibility of the legislative arm of government to legislate for the good governance of a country. Whenever there is a dispute on the interpretation of the law duly made, the Courts, being the judicial arm of government, are saddled with the responsibility of resolving the issue. The moment the controversy is settled, it is a duty on the executive arm of government to ensure compliance with the judicial decision.

                          The provision of Section 84 (12) of the Electoral Act, 2022, struck down, by Honourable Justice E.N. Anyadike was not the only Section in the Electoral Act that was nullified in the history of this country. In AG Abia State & Ors. v AG of the Federation (2002) LPELR – 611 (SC), the Apex Court found Sections 15, 20(1) & (4), 21 (1) and 25, the proviso to Section 110 (1), Sections 111, 112, 113, 114, 115(1) – (6), 119, 120, 121 and 122, of the Electoral Act, 2001, invalid. From 2002 to date the Supreme Court has consistently rejected any attempt by any persons or authorities to do any act which is an infraction of the Constitution (as it were and now as amended). See AG Abia State & Ors. v AG of the Federation (supra), APC & Ors v Karfi (2017) LPELR – 47024 (SC); Amaechi v INEC (2008) 5 NWLR (Pt.1080) (SC).

                          The Independent National Electoral Commission is a Federal Executive body empowered by the Constitution to conduct Presidential, Gubernatorial, National and State Houses of Assembly and Area Council elections. The body in discharging its responsibilities (one of which is conducting election) is independent and not to be subjected to the direction or control of any other authority or person. In complementing the Constitutional powers of INEC to conduct an election, the National Assembly in the Electoral Act, 2022, in my opinion, donate judicial function to the electoral umpire. To buttress my assertion, see Section 65 (1) of the Act which empowered the Commission to review declaration and return of an election on the grounds of infractions of the law or where the declaration and return were made under duress:

                          “(1) The decision of the returning officer shall be final in relation to any question arising from relating to –

                          unmarked ballot paper;

                          rejected ballot paper; and

                          declaration of scores of candidates and the return of a candidate:

                          officer on ballot paper.

                          Provided that the Commission shall have the power within seven days to review the declaration and return where the Commission determines that the said declaration and return was not made voluntarily or was made contrary to the provisions of the law, regulations and guidelines, and manual for the election….”

                          The National Assembly and independent National Electoral Commission are a creation of the Constitution (as amended). The general power of the National Assembly to legislate on electoral matters derived its legitimacy from the Grundnorm, as such, in law, the legislative bodies are not supposed to make any legislation that may contradict the basic structure of the Constitution which is the Supreme Law of the land.

                          Constitutionally, one of the responsibilities of INEC is to conduct elections within its competence. Any issue or dispute out of that election is within the exclusive jurisdiction of Courts/tribunals to determine them.  One of the basic structures of the Constitution (as amended) is the doctrine of Separation of Powers which has been firmly entrenched in the Supreme law. It is my humble view that, it is ultravires for the National Assembly, based on the provisions of Section 65 (1) of the Electoral Act, 2022, to empower INEC “within seven days to review the declaration and return where the Commission determines that the said declaration and return was not made voluntarily or was made contrary to the provisions of the law, regulations and guidelines, and manual for the election.”

                          The foregoing proviso in Sub-section (1) of Section 65 of the Electoral Act contradicts Sections 6 (6), (b); 239 (1), (a), (b) and 285 (1), (2) and (3) of the Constitution (as amended). These provisions donate powers to the Court of Appeal and Election Tribunals to hear and determine election petitions as to whether persons had been validly elected to the offices of the President, Vice President, Governors, Deputy Governors, Members of the Upper and Lower Legislative Houses and State Houses of Assembly and Area Councils. The provision of the Electoral Act under reference in my view has given the INEC judicial powers to determine the authenticity of declaration and return made by its returning officer alleged to have been made contrary to law or under duress.

                          The pertinent question is, why should INEC be a judge in its own cause? Its official, in this circumstance the returning officer, had made a declaration and return, and the same body is empowered to review the decision of its agent? That is contrary to one of the twin rules of natural justice that a person cannot be a judge in his own cause as contained in Section 36 of the Constitution (as amended).

                          Moreover, for INEC to determine any allegations of infractions of law in the return of election or declaration and return made under duress, the Commission has to receive a formal complaint, listen to evidence, assess the testimonies of witnesses, examine documents and decide the complaint either way. These exercises are within the exclusive powers of the court/tribunal. In Amaechi v INEC (supra), the Supreme Court, per Aderemi, JSC (as he then was) in an explicit language ruled that INEC lacks vires to exercise judicial function – “the Commission lacks the power to disqualify any candidate on its own. The power … belongs exclusively to the …. Court…” In AC & Anor v. INEC (2007) LPELR – 66 (SC) the Apex Court through Honorable Justice Katsina-Alu (of blessed memory) in a strong language held that:

                          “The jurisdiction and authority of the courts of this country cannot be unsolved by either the Executive or the Legislative branch of the Federal or State Government under any guise or pretext whatsoever.”

                          The Court of Appeal in Abana v Obi (2004) 10 NWLR (Pt. 881) aptly stated where the functions of INEC start and ends per Honorable Justice Isa Ayo Salami (as he then was) at p. 367, paras. C – G:

                          “…the duties of INEC under Section 78 of the Constitution ends with the declaration of the result and return those of the tribunal and courts kicks off with conclusion of the conduct of the election by the declaration and return of winner under section 59(c) of the Act. The Commission’s supervisory jurisdiction of the returning officer probably exists by way of vetting the result before it was announced and return made. Thereafter there is no longer “conduct of election” to be supervised by the Commission. The power of the Commission is to ensure that the registration of voters and conduct of the election are properly carried out but, once it goes awry, after the result is declared it is incompetent to correct the error, resort would have to be made to the tribunal or court.”

                          Similarly, in Idris & Anor v. Salik & Ors (2009) LPELR – 8518 (CA) Honourable Justice Abubakar Abdulkadir Jega (of blessed memory) followed the reasoning of the Court of Appeal in Abana v Obi which drew inspiration from the Apex Court’s decision in Okunola v. Ogundiran (1962)1 SCNLR 150 where the Supreme Court through a lead decision of Honourable Justice Adetokumbo Ademola CJF (as he then was) affirmed the decision of trial High Court which pronounced that once the declaration of result and return was made any subsequent declaration and return is invalid.

                          Application of Section 65 (1) Based on Logic and Commonsense

                          Honourable Justice Nwali Sylvester Ngwuta, JSC (of blessed memory) in Nigerian Ports PLC v Beecham Pharmaceutical PLC (2012) LPLELR – 15538 (SC) opined that “Often times, law and logic cannot be separated.” It is a fact that the atmosphere of most of the venues where declarations and returns of elections are being made in Nigeria are charged or not conducive for the Commission to contemplate reviewing declaration and return of an election made by the returning officer.

                          The first challenge INEC will face is that the provision of Section 65 (1) of the Electoral Act will open floodgates of formal complaints by political parties and their candidates through their lawyers, challenging declaration and return of election on either of the grounds provided by the law. How will INEC determine the authenticity of the complaints? What rules will it use in settling the dispute? Does INEC have competent staff to handle such complaints?

                          It will be difficult for the supporters and agents of the contestants returned as winners to allow the Commission period of seven (7) days to review and possibly set aside the victories of their candidates. Certainly, any attempt to alter the result even if there are genuine errors in my view might be difficult for the Commission to have the comfort of correcting the errors. Just imagined during the Orubebe saga, Professor Jega was empowered to look into the allegations raised by Mr. Orubebe.

                          I am sure any attempt by the Professor of Political Science to consider the complaints would have met serious resistance. It will serve the best interest of the public and the safety of INEC staff for the Commission to be circumspect in exercising the powers donated to them by the National Assembly under Section 65 (1) of the Electoral Act, 2022.

                          Conclusion

                          Application of Section 65 (1) of the Electoral Act, 2022 will be a huge challenge to INEC. Legally speaking the provision is faulty and its application is bound to be chaotic. Determination of whether a declaration was made in accordance with the law is the exclusive jurisdictions of the Courts/Tribunals. Whoever alleges that declaration has been made contrary to law should approach the appropriate Court/Tribunal manned by persons with expertise to determine the claim. To empower INEC, the body that conducted the election through its agents, to review the declaration and return made by its ad-hoc or permanent staff, is awkward. It is my suggestion that the National Assembly should take immediate step to amend the Electoral Act and repeal the provision of Section 65 (1) of the Electoral Act, 2022. In the event, the provision remains in the law there is need for the Independent National Electoral Commission to be circumspect in exercising that power.

                          Dr. Musa Adamu Aliyu is the Attorney-General of Jigawa State

                          Share your thoughts on this piece Interrogating Power of INEC to Review Return of Winner of Election Made by its Returning Officer within the Context of Constitution (as amended) and Logic with OnlineNews in the comments section.

                          Tags: Context of ConstitutionDr Musa Adamu AliyuElectionINECInterrogating PowerReturn of WinnerReturning OfficerReview
                          Previous Post

                          David Umahi withdraws motion to stay execution of judgment on removal 

                          Next Post

                          Kano judges not ready for e-adjudication, says attorney-general

                          Next Post
                          Court sentences man, death, hanging, raping, killing, landlady

                          Kano judges not ready for e-adjudication, says attorney-general

                          Leave a Reply Cancel reply

                          Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

                          Stay Connected

                          • 761 Followers
                          • 23.9k Followers
                          • 99 Subscribers
                          • Trending
                          • Comments
                          • Latest
                          Lawyers, Properly Dressed, Right of Audience, Kano Sharia Courts 

                          Lawyers Not Properly Dressed Would No Longer Get Right of Audience in Kano Sharia Courts

                          January 5, 2022
                          Usman Umar Fari, INEC, Constitutional Backing, Review, Kano Governorship Election, Return, Declaration, Abba Kabir Yusuf, APC, NNPC

                          Does INEC Posses Constitutional Backing to Review Kano Governorship Election Return and Declaration?

                          February 29, 2024
                          Baffa Babba DanAgundi, Justice Nasiru Saminu, Furious, Kano High Court, slams, KAROTA MD, lawlessness, illegality

                          Kano High Court slams KAROTA MD over lawlessness, illegality

                          February 28, 2022
                          Abdulmumini Jibrin Kofa, Tinubu Support Group, Muslim-Muslim, Presidential Ticket, 2023

                          Tinubu Group Says Nothing Wrong with Muslim-Muslim Presidential Ticket in 2023

                          January 4, 2022
                          Walin Kazaure, Babangida Hussaini, Muhammadu Buhari, abandoned projects

                          Walin Kazaure hails Buhari for executing 50-year abandoned projects

                          3
                          Lawyers, Properly Dressed, Right of Audience, Kano Sharia Courts 

                          Lawyers Not Properly Dressed Would No Longer Get Right of Audience in Kano Sharia Courts

                          2
                          BASHIR TOFA'S BURIAL, Ganduje's Government, Goofed, Bala Ibrahim

                          BASHIR TOFA’S BURIAL: Again Ganduje’s Government Goofed

                          2
                          Bishop Mathew Hassan Kukah, Mend, Broken Nation, Easter Metaphor, Nigeria Muhammadu Buhari

                          To Mend A Broken Nation: The Easter Metaphor On Nigeria By Bishop Mathew Kukah

                          2
                          Sule Lamido, N45 BILLION DEBT, MKO Abiola, DoublE cheating, Nigeria, military junta

                          N45 BILLION DEBT: MKO Abiola doubly cheated by Nigeria’s military junta

                          May 14, 2025
                          Nyesom Wike, PDP, Smartness, Zoning, Presidential ticket

                          Wike queries PDP’s ‘smartness’ over zoning of presidential ticket

                          May 13, 2025
                          2025 AMVCA, full list, Winners, Sani Mu’azu, Femi Adebayo

                          See full list as Sani Mu’azu, Femi Adebayo, others win at 2025 AMVCA

                          May 11, 2025
                          Pope Leo XIV , New pope, black, Farooq A. Kperogi

                          The new pope is “black,” now what? by Farooq Kperogi

                          May 11, 2025

                          Recent News

                          Sule Lamido, N45 BILLION DEBT, MKO Abiola, DoublE cheating, Nigeria, military junta

                          N45 BILLION DEBT: MKO Abiola doubly cheated by Nigeria’s military junta

                          May 14, 2025
                          Nyesom Wike, PDP, Smartness, Zoning, Presidential ticket

                          Wike queries PDP’s ‘smartness’ over zoning of presidential ticket

                          May 13, 2025
                          2025 AMVCA, full list, Winners, Sani Mu’azu, Femi Adebayo

                          See full list as Sani Mu’azu, Femi Adebayo, others win at 2025 AMVCA

                          May 11, 2025
                          Pope Leo XIV , New pope, black, Farooq A. Kperogi

                          The new pope is “black,” now what? by Farooq Kperogi

                          May 11, 2025
                          ONLINE NEWS NIGERIA

                          Online News Nigeria is an online news medium registered in Nigeria to disseminate verified information on a wide range of issues happening in the country and around the world.

                          Follow Us

                          Browse by Category

                          • AFCON 2021
                          • AFCON 2023
                          • Africa
                          • Africa
                          • Akwa Ibom
                          • Anambra State
                          • Anti-corruption
                          • Asia
                          • Automobile
                          • Basketball
                          • Books
                          • Boxing
                          • Boxing
                          • Business
                          • Celebrity
                          • China
                          • Column
                          • COVID-19
                          • Crime
                          • Cryptocurrency
                          • Ebonyi State
                          • Economy
                          • Education
                          • English Premier League
                          • Entertainment
                          • Enugu State
                          • Europe
                          • Europe
                          • Featured
                          • Football
                          • For the records
                          • Gas and electricity
                          • Guinness World Records
                          • Health
                          • Insurance
                          • International
                          • International
                          • Internatonal
                          • Intimate Affairs
                          • Intimate Affairs
                          • Jigawa State
                          • Kaduna State
                          • Kano
                          • Kogi State
                          • Kwara State
                          • La Liga
                          • La Liga
                          • Lagos State
                          • Law
                          • Ligue 1
                          • Literature
                          • Media
                          • Middle East
                          • News
                          • Nigeria
                          • NPFL
                          • Oil and Gas
                          • Olympics
                          • Opinon
                          • Personalities
                          • Politics
                          • Power and Electricity
                          • Press Release
                          • Qatar 2022
                          • Relationship
                          • Religion
                          • Religon
                          • Rivers State
                          • Security
                          • Sports
                          • Telecommunication
                          • Tourism
                          • Tribite
                          • Uncategorized
                          • United Kingdom
                          • United Nation
                          • UNITED NATIONS
                          • United States

                          Recent News

                          Sule Lamido, N45 BILLION DEBT, MKO Abiola, DoublE cheating, Nigeria, military junta

                          N45 BILLION DEBT: MKO Abiola doubly cheated by Nigeria’s military junta

                          May 14, 2025
                          Nyesom Wike, PDP, Smartness, Zoning, Presidential ticket

                          Wike queries PDP’s ‘smartness’ over zoning of presidential ticket

                          May 13, 2025
                          • Home
                          • About
                          • Privacy & Policy
                          • Contact

                          © 2025 ONLINE NEWS - Developed by ENGRMKS & CO..

                          No Result
                          View All Result
                          • Home
                          • News
                          • Entertainment
                          • Politics
                          • International
                          • Law
                          • Security
                          • Sports

                          © 2025 ONLINE NEWS - Developed by ENGRMKS & CO..